Retention modeling is a crucial part of people analytics, providing insights into employee turnover, identifying flight risks, and guiding strategies to retain top talent. But what happens when you're working with limited data? In many organizations, especially smaller ones or those early in their analytics journey, people analysts often face challenges like incomplete datasets, few data points, or inconsistent tracking of key employee metrics. This doesn't mean you can't build effective retention models—it just requires a thoughtful approach and the right strategies.

In this article, we’ll explore practical methods for conducting retention modeling with limited data, highlight some key considerations, and offer actionable steps to extract the most value from your available information.

When building retention models, having access to a large, comprehensive dataset is ideal. More data generally allows for more accurate predictions and stronger statistical inferences. However, in the real world, many organizations—particularly smaller companies or departments—don’t have the luxury of vast datasets. The common challenges include:

• Small Sample Sizes: A limited number of employees or a short time frame to analyze turnover trends.
• Incomplete Data: Missing data on important predictors such as employee performance, engagement scores, or compensation history.
• Noisy Data: Data that has inconsistencies due to manual entry or infrequent updates, leading to unreliable predictors.
• Few Predictive Variables: Lack of diversity in the variables tracked, which limits your ability to explore the drivers of turnover.

These challenges can make it difficult to build a robust retention model, but they are not insurmountable.

Strategies for Building Retention Models with Limited Data

Despite these constraints, there are effective ways to approach retention modeling when data is limited. Below are some strategies you can use to maximize the insights you gain from small or incomplete datasets.

1. Prioritize Key Variables

In retention modeling, not all variables are equally important. When dealing with limited data, it’s essential to focus on the most critical predictors of turnover. Typically, some of the most influential variables include:

• Tenure: Longer-tenured employees tend to have lower turnover risk.
• Engagement: Employees with low engagement scores are more likely to leave.
• Performance Ratings: High or low performance scores can both indicate turnover risk, depending on the organization.
• Compensation: Pay satisfaction often correlates with retention.

By prioritizing these core variables, you can build a simpler model that still captures the key factors driving turnover.

2. Consider Logistic Regression, But Explore Other Methods Too

Logistic regression can be a powerful and relatively straightforward tool for predicting binary outcomes, such as whether an employee will stay or leave. It's useful in identifying the key drivers of turnover, especially when working with limited data. For example, you can use logistic regression to predict turnover based on variables like tenure, engagement, and performance ratings. This method helps you understand the probability that an employee will leave and highlights the most significant factors contributing to that risk.

However, logistic regression isn't the only approach to solving retention challenges. If you're trying to understand not just who is leaving but also when employees are likely to leave, survival models (such as Cox Proportional Hazards) can be a better fit. Survival analysis focuses on the time until an event occurs, making it a strong tool for assessing employee turnover patterns over time. This method can provide insight into when employees are most at risk of leaving and help HR teams time interventions more effectively.

3. Qualitative Data: Focus Groups and Feedback

While predictive modeling offers valuable insights, it’s important to acknowledge that quantitative data alone may not provide the full picture. In some cases, gathering qualitative insights through focus groups, exit interviews, or employee feedback surveys can be just as important, if not more so, than modeling. These methods allow employees to express their reasons for disengagement or leaving in their own words, helping HR teams identify underlying issues that may not surface in quantitative data alone.

For instance, if engagement scores indicate dissatisfaction but the specific reasons aren’t clear, conducting focus groups with employees who are at risk of leaving could help uncover actionable insights. You may discover that factors like work-life balance or management support play a larger role in turnover than previously anticipated. Combining these qualitative insights with your retention models ensures a more holistic approach to understanding and addressing turnover.

4. Use Multiple Methods for Comprehensive Insights

The key takeaway is that retention modeling doesn't always require advanced modeling techniques, and focusing solely on quantitative methods like logistic regression or survival analysis might miss crucial human elements. By incorporating both quantitative and qualitative data—such as focus groups, employee sentiment surveys, and one-on-one feedback—you can build a more robust understanding of employee retention. In doing so, you’ll provide HR teams with both predictive analytics and actionable, context-driven insights.

5. Leverage External Benchmarks and Industry Data

When internal data is scarce, external benchmarks can be an invaluable resource. Many HR organizations and industry studies provide general turnover rates, compensation benchmarks, and engagement trends by industry, location, or role. While external data cannot replace internal metrics, it can provide useful context for your model and help you calibrate predictions when internal data is sparse.

For example, if your organization doesn't track detailed performance data but industry benchmarks indicate that high performers in your industry typically have lower turnover rates, you can use that insight to adjust your modeling assumptions.

5. Simplify the Model

It's tempting to include as many predictors as possible in your model to improve accuracy. However, with limited data, simpler models often perform better. A simple model with just a few carefully selected variables is less likely to overfit the data (a problem where the model is too closely tailored to the training data and performs poorly on new data).

Simplified models are easier to interpret and communicate to stakeholders. For example, a model with just tenure, engagement score, and performance rating is not only manageable but also easier for HR teams to act upon.

6. Apply Regularization Techniques

When dealing with limited data, overfitting is a common concern. Regularization techniques like Lasso regression (Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator) can help by penalizing the model for including too many predictors or over-relying on noisy data. Lasso regression effectively selects the most important variables, ensuring that your model remains simple and doesn’t overfit the small dataset.

In cases where you have a small number of predictors, Lasso regression can help identify the most impactful factors contributing to turnover, even when data is limited.

Example:

Let’s consider a scenario where you're building a retention model for a company with 100 employees. The company has limited data, only tracking basic information such as tenure, engagement scores, and performance ratings.

Key Variables:

• Tenure (Years at company)
• Engagement Score (1-5)
• Performance Rating (Low, Medium, High)

Approaches:

1. Logistic Regression: Use logistic regression to predict whether employees will leave based on these three variables. The model might show that engagement score is the most significant predictor of turnover, with employees scoring 2 or below having a 70% higher likelihood of leaving within the next 12 months.
2. Survival Analysis: Use a survival model to analyze when employees are likely to leave. The model could show that new employees have a higher likelihood of leaving within their first year, which suggests the need for interventions like onboarding improvements or mentorship programs.
3. Focus Groups: Complement the model with focus groups to understand the qualitative reasons behind low engagement scores. You might discover that employees are unhappy with work-life balance or feel undervalued in their roles—insights that quantitative models alone might not reveal.

Actionable Insights:

• Engagement Interventions: Focus on improving engagement for employees who score low on engagement surveys.
• Tenure-Based Retention: New employees in their first year have a higher turnover risk, suggesting the need for onboarding improvements or mentorship programs.
• Qualitative Feedback: Use data gathered from focus groups to address work-life balance or leadership-related concerns, which might not be reflected directly in your models.

Conclusion: Making the Most of Limited Data

While working with limited data presents challenges, it doesn't mean you can't build effective retention models in people analytics. By focusing on key variables, using logistic regression or survival models when appropriate, simplifying the model, and leveraging techniques like regularization and imputation, you can still generate meaningful insights. Additionally, incorporating qualitative methods like focus groups provides valuable context that complements your data-driven analysis.

As your organization grows and improves its data collection practices, your models will become more sophisticated. But even with limited data, you can provide actionable insights that improve retention and drive better decision-making.

At DataSkillUp, we help people analysts build the skills necessary to harness the power of data-driven techniques while also integrating qualitative approaches. If you’re ready to take your HR strategies to the next level, reach out to us for personalized training and coaching.

Book a 60-minute discovery call to learn how we can help you achieve your People Analytics goals here.

Learn more about our coaching programs here.

Connect with us on LinkedIn here.

‍

‍